Debates on urban reconstruction through reclamation of traditional water scenery in 1940s Tokyo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The Tokyo Metropolitan Government, seeking to break an impasse in its state-sponsored war-damage reconstruction efforts after the Second World War, presented proposals in the late 1940s to reclaim centuries-old canals in its central area to dispose of wartime rubble and create land for redevelopment. The Government also received a proposal forwarded by Japan’s professional baseball association to reclaim a scenic pond in central Tokyo and build a baseball stadium there, and it responded favourably. Two canal reclamation projects were realized, but the pond reclamation was eventually abandoned. These reclamation proposals provoked debates of varying intensity over the loss of traditional scenery as part of urban reconstruction. This paper examines those debates and interprets their meaning within the history of Japan’s city planning. It notes the awakening of concern for land use planning after reclamation – in particular, the preservation of locations of scenic value – in the context of urban reconstruction. The paper also considers the limited nature of civic space for public discourse and debate over planning proposals and a collusive aspect of the inter-governmental relationship in city planning. It also considers the attitudes towards reclamation displayed by Hideaki Ishikawa, the principal planner of Tokyo’s war-damage reconstruction plan.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-24
Number of pages24
JournalPlanning Perspectives
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2017 Oct 28

Fingerprint

reconstruction
water
planning
canal
damages
pond
Japan
damage
professional association
redevelopment
land use planning
World War
land use
discourse
history
Values
city

Keywords

  • Hideaki Ishikawa
  • Japan city planning
  • reclamation of traditional water scenes
  • Tokyo
  • Tokyo Metropolitan Government
  • urban reconstruction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geography, Planning and Development

Cite this

@article{d7e953df46314dfd8140bf5458ce0950,
title = "Debates on urban reconstruction through reclamation of traditional water scenery in 1940s Tokyo",
abstract = "The Tokyo Metropolitan Government, seeking to break an impasse in its state-sponsored war-damage reconstruction efforts after the Second World War, presented proposals in the late 1940s to reclaim centuries-old canals in its central area to dispose of wartime rubble and create land for redevelopment. The Government also received a proposal forwarded by Japan’s professional baseball association to reclaim a scenic pond in central Tokyo and build a baseball stadium there, and it responded favourably. Two canal reclamation projects were realized, but the pond reclamation was eventually abandoned. These reclamation proposals provoked debates of varying intensity over the loss of traditional scenery as part of urban reconstruction. This paper examines those debates and interprets their meaning within the history of Japan’s city planning. It notes the awakening of concern for land use planning after reclamation – in particular, the preservation of locations of scenic value – in the context of urban reconstruction. The paper also considers the limited nature of civic space for public discourse and debate over planning proposals and a collusive aspect of the inter-governmental relationship in city planning. It also considers the attitudes towards reclamation displayed by Hideaki Ishikawa, the principal planner of Tokyo’s war-damage reconstruction plan.",
keywords = "Hideaki Ishikawa, Japan city planning, reclamation of traditional water scenes, Tokyo, Tokyo Metropolitan Government, urban reconstruction",
author = "Junichi Hasegawa",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
day = "28",
doi = "10.1080/02665433.2017.1393630",
language = "English",
pages = "1--24",
journal = "Planning Perspectives",
issn = "0266-5433",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Debates on urban reconstruction through reclamation of traditional water scenery in 1940s Tokyo

AU - Hasegawa, Junichi

PY - 2017/10/28

Y1 - 2017/10/28

N2 - The Tokyo Metropolitan Government, seeking to break an impasse in its state-sponsored war-damage reconstruction efforts after the Second World War, presented proposals in the late 1940s to reclaim centuries-old canals in its central area to dispose of wartime rubble and create land for redevelopment. The Government also received a proposal forwarded by Japan’s professional baseball association to reclaim a scenic pond in central Tokyo and build a baseball stadium there, and it responded favourably. Two canal reclamation projects were realized, but the pond reclamation was eventually abandoned. These reclamation proposals provoked debates of varying intensity over the loss of traditional scenery as part of urban reconstruction. This paper examines those debates and interprets their meaning within the history of Japan’s city planning. It notes the awakening of concern for land use planning after reclamation – in particular, the preservation of locations of scenic value – in the context of urban reconstruction. The paper also considers the limited nature of civic space for public discourse and debate over planning proposals and a collusive aspect of the inter-governmental relationship in city planning. It also considers the attitudes towards reclamation displayed by Hideaki Ishikawa, the principal planner of Tokyo’s war-damage reconstruction plan.

AB - The Tokyo Metropolitan Government, seeking to break an impasse in its state-sponsored war-damage reconstruction efforts after the Second World War, presented proposals in the late 1940s to reclaim centuries-old canals in its central area to dispose of wartime rubble and create land for redevelopment. The Government also received a proposal forwarded by Japan’s professional baseball association to reclaim a scenic pond in central Tokyo and build a baseball stadium there, and it responded favourably. Two canal reclamation projects were realized, but the pond reclamation was eventually abandoned. These reclamation proposals provoked debates of varying intensity over the loss of traditional scenery as part of urban reconstruction. This paper examines those debates and interprets their meaning within the history of Japan’s city planning. It notes the awakening of concern for land use planning after reclamation – in particular, the preservation of locations of scenic value – in the context of urban reconstruction. The paper also considers the limited nature of civic space for public discourse and debate over planning proposals and a collusive aspect of the inter-governmental relationship in city planning. It also considers the attitudes towards reclamation displayed by Hideaki Ishikawa, the principal planner of Tokyo’s war-damage reconstruction plan.

KW - Hideaki Ishikawa

KW - Japan city planning

KW - reclamation of traditional water scenes

KW - Tokyo

KW - Tokyo Metropolitan Government

KW - urban reconstruction

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85032370672&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85032370672&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/02665433.2017.1393630

DO - 10.1080/02665433.2017.1393630

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85032370672

SP - 1

EP - 24

JO - Planning Perspectives

JF - Planning Perspectives

SN - 0266-5433

ER -