Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel: Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials

J. W. Fawcett, A. Curt, J. D. Steeves, W. P. Coleman, M. H. Tuszynski, D. Lammertse, P. F. Bartlett, A. R. Blight, V. Dietz, J. Ditunno, B. H. Dobkin, L. A. Havton, P. H. Ellaway, M. G. Fehlings, A. Privat, R. Grossman, J. D. Guest, N. Kleitman, Masaya Nakamura, M. GaviriaD. Short

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

463 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The International Campaign for Cures of Spinal Cord Injury Paralysis (ICCP) supported an international panel tasked with reviewing the methodology for clinical trials in spinal cord injury (SCI), and making recommendations on the conduct of future trials. This is the first of four papers. Here, we examine the spontaneous rate of recovery after SCI and resulting consequences for achieving statistically significant results in clinical trials. We have reanalysed data from the Sygen trial to provide some of this information. Almost all people living with SCI show some recovery of motor function below the initial spinal injury level. While the spontaneous recovery of motor function in patients with motor-complete SCI is fairly limited and predictable, recovery in incomplete SCI patients (American spinal injury Association impairment scale (AIS) C and AIS D) is both more substantial and highly variable. With motor complete lesions (AIS A/AIS B) the majority of functional return is within the zone of partial preservation, and may be sufficient to reclassify the injury level to a lower spinal level. The vast majority of recovery occurs in the first 3 months, but a small amount can persist for up to18 months or longer. Some sensory recovery occurs after SCI, on roughly the same time course as motor recovery. Based on previous data of the magnitude of spontaneous recovery after SCI, as measured by changes in ASIA motor scores, power calculations suggest that the number of subjects required to achieve a significant result from a trial declines considerably as the start of the study is delayed after SCI. Trials of treatments that are most efficacious when given soon after injury will therefore, require larger patient numbers than trials of treatments that are effective at later time points. As AIS B patients show greater spontaneous recovery than AIS A patients, the number of AIS A patients requiring to be enrolled into a trial is lower. This factor will have to be balanced against the possibility that some treatments will be more effective in incomplete patients. Trials involving motor incomplete SCI patients, or trials where an accurate assessment of AIS grade cannot be made before the start of the trial, will require large subject numbers and/or better objective assessment methods.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)190-205
Number of pages16
JournalSpinal Cord
Volume45
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2007 Mar 30

Fingerprint

Spinal Cord Injuries
Clinical Trials
Guidelines
Therapeutics
Spinal Injuries
Recovery of Function
Wounds and Injuries
Paralysis

Keywords

  • ASIA
  • Clinical assessment
  • Clinical examination
  • Clinical trial
  • Motor system
  • Power calculation
  • Sensory system
  • Spinal cord injury

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel : Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials. / Fawcett, J. W.; Curt, A.; Steeves, J. D.; Coleman, W. P.; Tuszynski, M. H.; Lammertse, D.; Bartlett, P. F.; Blight, A. R.; Dietz, V.; Ditunno, J.; Dobkin, B. H.; Havton, L. A.; Ellaway, P. H.; Fehlings, M. G.; Privat, A.; Grossman, R.; Guest, J. D.; Kleitman, N.; Nakamura, Masaya; Gaviria, M.; Short, D.

In: Spinal Cord, Vol. 45, No. 3, 30.03.2007, p. 190-205.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fawcett, JW, Curt, A, Steeves, JD, Coleman, WP, Tuszynski, MH, Lammertse, D, Bartlett, PF, Blight, AR, Dietz, V, Ditunno, J, Dobkin, BH, Havton, LA, Ellaway, PH, Fehlings, MG, Privat, A, Grossman, R, Guest, JD, Kleitman, N, Nakamura, M, Gaviria, M & Short, D 2007, 'Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel: Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials', Spinal Cord, vol. 45, no. 3, pp. 190-205. https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.sc.3102007
Fawcett, J. W. ; Curt, A. ; Steeves, J. D. ; Coleman, W. P. ; Tuszynski, M. H. ; Lammertse, D. ; Bartlett, P. F. ; Blight, A. R. ; Dietz, V. ; Ditunno, J. ; Dobkin, B. H. ; Havton, L. A. ; Ellaway, P. H. ; Fehlings, M. G. ; Privat, A. ; Grossman, R. ; Guest, J. D. ; Kleitman, N. ; Nakamura, Masaya ; Gaviria, M. ; Short, D. / Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel : Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials. In: Spinal Cord. 2007 ; Vol. 45, No. 3. pp. 190-205.
@article{0ac9855a5ab94af5aa968361c88c2179,
title = "Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel: Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials",
abstract = "The International Campaign for Cures of Spinal Cord Injury Paralysis (ICCP) supported an international panel tasked with reviewing the methodology for clinical trials in spinal cord injury (SCI), and making recommendations on the conduct of future trials. This is the first of four papers. Here, we examine the spontaneous rate of recovery after SCI and resulting consequences for achieving statistically significant results in clinical trials. We have reanalysed data from the Sygen trial to provide some of this information. Almost all people living with SCI show some recovery of motor function below the initial spinal injury level. While the spontaneous recovery of motor function in patients with motor-complete SCI is fairly limited and predictable, recovery in incomplete SCI patients (American spinal injury Association impairment scale (AIS) C and AIS D) is both more substantial and highly variable. With motor complete lesions (AIS A/AIS B) the majority of functional return is within the zone of partial preservation, and may be sufficient to reclassify the injury level to a lower spinal level. The vast majority of recovery occurs in the first 3 months, but a small amount can persist for up to18 months or longer. Some sensory recovery occurs after SCI, on roughly the same time course as motor recovery. Based on previous data of the magnitude of spontaneous recovery after SCI, as measured by changes in ASIA motor scores, power calculations suggest that the number of subjects required to achieve a significant result from a trial declines considerably as the start of the study is delayed after SCI. Trials of treatments that are most efficacious when given soon after injury will therefore, require larger patient numbers than trials of treatments that are effective at later time points. As AIS B patients show greater spontaneous recovery than AIS A patients, the number of AIS A patients requiring to be enrolled into a trial is lower. This factor will have to be balanced against the possibility that some treatments will be more effective in incomplete patients. Trials involving motor incomplete SCI patients, or trials where an accurate assessment of AIS grade cannot be made before the start of the trial, will require large subject numbers and/or better objective assessment methods.",
keywords = "ASIA, Clinical assessment, Clinical examination, Clinical trial, Motor system, Power calculation, Sensory system, Spinal cord injury",
author = "Fawcett, {J. W.} and A. Curt and Steeves, {J. D.} and Coleman, {W. P.} and Tuszynski, {M. H.} and D. Lammertse and Bartlett, {P. F.} and Blight, {A. R.} and V. Dietz and J. Ditunno and Dobkin, {B. H.} and Havton, {L. A.} and Ellaway, {P. H.} and Fehlings, {M. G.} and A. Privat and R. Grossman and Guest, {J. D.} and N. Kleitman and Masaya Nakamura and M. Gaviria and D. Short",
year = "2007",
month = "3",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1038/sj.sc.3102007",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "190--205",
journal = "Spinal Cord",
issn = "1362-4393",
publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Guidelines for the conduct of clinical trials for spinal cord injury as developed by the ICCP panel

T2 - Spontaneous recovery after spinal cord injury and statistical power needed for therapeutic clinical trials

AU - Fawcett, J. W.

AU - Curt, A.

AU - Steeves, J. D.

AU - Coleman, W. P.

AU - Tuszynski, M. H.

AU - Lammertse, D.

AU - Bartlett, P. F.

AU - Blight, A. R.

AU - Dietz, V.

AU - Ditunno, J.

AU - Dobkin, B. H.

AU - Havton, L. A.

AU - Ellaway, P. H.

AU - Fehlings, M. G.

AU - Privat, A.

AU - Grossman, R.

AU - Guest, J. D.

AU - Kleitman, N.

AU - Nakamura, Masaya

AU - Gaviria, M.

AU - Short, D.

PY - 2007/3/30

Y1 - 2007/3/30

N2 - The International Campaign for Cures of Spinal Cord Injury Paralysis (ICCP) supported an international panel tasked with reviewing the methodology for clinical trials in spinal cord injury (SCI), and making recommendations on the conduct of future trials. This is the first of four papers. Here, we examine the spontaneous rate of recovery after SCI and resulting consequences for achieving statistically significant results in clinical trials. We have reanalysed data from the Sygen trial to provide some of this information. Almost all people living with SCI show some recovery of motor function below the initial spinal injury level. While the spontaneous recovery of motor function in patients with motor-complete SCI is fairly limited and predictable, recovery in incomplete SCI patients (American spinal injury Association impairment scale (AIS) C and AIS D) is both more substantial and highly variable. With motor complete lesions (AIS A/AIS B) the majority of functional return is within the zone of partial preservation, and may be sufficient to reclassify the injury level to a lower spinal level. The vast majority of recovery occurs in the first 3 months, but a small amount can persist for up to18 months or longer. Some sensory recovery occurs after SCI, on roughly the same time course as motor recovery. Based on previous data of the magnitude of spontaneous recovery after SCI, as measured by changes in ASIA motor scores, power calculations suggest that the number of subjects required to achieve a significant result from a trial declines considerably as the start of the study is delayed after SCI. Trials of treatments that are most efficacious when given soon after injury will therefore, require larger patient numbers than trials of treatments that are effective at later time points. As AIS B patients show greater spontaneous recovery than AIS A patients, the number of AIS A patients requiring to be enrolled into a trial is lower. This factor will have to be balanced against the possibility that some treatments will be more effective in incomplete patients. Trials involving motor incomplete SCI patients, or trials where an accurate assessment of AIS grade cannot be made before the start of the trial, will require large subject numbers and/or better objective assessment methods.

AB - The International Campaign for Cures of Spinal Cord Injury Paralysis (ICCP) supported an international panel tasked with reviewing the methodology for clinical trials in spinal cord injury (SCI), and making recommendations on the conduct of future trials. This is the first of four papers. Here, we examine the spontaneous rate of recovery after SCI and resulting consequences for achieving statistically significant results in clinical trials. We have reanalysed data from the Sygen trial to provide some of this information. Almost all people living with SCI show some recovery of motor function below the initial spinal injury level. While the spontaneous recovery of motor function in patients with motor-complete SCI is fairly limited and predictable, recovery in incomplete SCI patients (American spinal injury Association impairment scale (AIS) C and AIS D) is both more substantial and highly variable. With motor complete lesions (AIS A/AIS B) the majority of functional return is within the zone of partial preservation, and may be sufficient to reclassify the injury level to a lower spinal level. The vast majority of recovery occurs in the first 3 months, but a small amount can persist for up to18 months or longer. Some sensory recovery occurs after SCI, on roughly the same time course as motor recovery. Based on previous data of the magnitude of spontaneous recovery after SCI, as measured by changes in ASIA motor scores, power calculations suggest that the number of subjects required to achieve a significant result from a trial declines considerably as the start of the study is delayed after SCI. Trials of treatments that are most efficacious when given soon after injury will therefore, require larger patient numbers than trials of treatments that are effective at later time points. As AIS B patients show greater spontaneous recovery than AIS A patients, the number of AIS A patients requiring to be enrolled into a trial is lower. This factor will have to be balanced against the possibility that some treatments will be more effective in incomplete patients. Trials involving motor incomplete SCI patients, or trials where an accurate assessment of AIS grade cannot be made before the start of the trial, will require large subject numbers and/or better objective assessment methods.

KW - ASIA

KW - Clinical assessment

KW - Clinical examination

KW - Clinical trial

KW - Motor system

KW - Power calculation

KW - Sensory system

KW - Spinal cord injury

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33847391178&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33847391178&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1038/sj.sc.3102007

DO - 10.1038/sj.sc.3102007

M3 - Article

C2 - 17179973

AN - SCOPUS:33847391178

VL - 45

SP - 190

EP - 205

JO - Spinal Cord

JF - Spinal Cord

SN - 1362-4393

IS - 3

ER -