How Rousseau read Hume’s Political Discourses: hints of unexpected agreement in their views of money and luxury

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Despite mounting scholarship on the Rousseau–Smith connection, the possibility of overlap between the Humean and Rousseauian views of commercial society has not been explored. This is due to opposing views held by these two thinkers on this issue. However, Rousseau in the Confessions recorded a brief, but shrewd impressions on Hume’s Political Discourses, which he held before meeting Hume. In these comments, Rousseau, unlike his other French contemporaries, noted some republican aspects lurking in Hume’s political and economic essays. Moreover, after his two Discourses, Rousseau composed several other important works in which he revealed his more ‘mature’ economic arguments. Careful readings of these textual clues indicate that, in striking parallel with Hume, Rousseau conducts a thoughtful experiment on the drastic change in the quantity of money and elaborates on the significance of industry and a certain type of luxury. Our purpose here is not to prove that Hume’s Political Discourses directly influenced Rousseau’s later writings, but to measure the extent to which Rousseau could share the Scot’s economic ideas by considering that the former may well have read the latter.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of the History of Economic Thought
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2018 Jan 1

Fingerprint

Economics
Political Discourse
Luxury
Discourse
Commercial Society
David Hume
Thinkers
Industry
Overlap
Republican
Experiment

Keywords

  • enlightenment
  • Luxury
  • quantity theory of money
  • republicanism

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities(all)
  • Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous)
  • History and Philosophy of Science

Cite this

@article{c6b107beea974d66b5afc4dbf9cb5f45,
title = "How Rousseau read Hume’s Political Discourses: hints of unexpected agreement in their views of money and luxury",
abstract = "Despite mounting scholarship on the Rousseau–Smith connection, the possibility of overlap between the Humean and Rousseauian views of commercial society has not been explored. This is due to opposing views held by these two thinkers on this issue. However, Rousseau in the Confessions recorded a brief, but shrewd impressions on Hume’s Political Discourses, which he held before meeting Hume. In these comments, Rousseau, unlike his other French contemporaries, noted some republican aspects lurking in Hume’s political and economic essays. Moreover, after his two Discourses, Rousseau composed several other important works in which he revealed his more ‘mature’ economic arguments. Careful readings of these textual clues indicate that, in striking parallel with Hume, Rousseau conducts a thoughtful experiment on the drastic change in the quantity of money and elaborates on the significance of industry and a certain type of luxury. Our purpose here is not to prove that Hume’s Political Discourses directly influenced Rousseau’s later writings, but to measure the extent to which Rousseau could share the Scot’s economic ideas by considering that the former may well have read the latter.",
keywords = "enlightenment, Luxury, quantity theory of money, republicanism",
author = "Ryu Susato",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/09672567.2018.1499788",
language = "English",
journal = "European Journal of the History of Economic Thought",
issn = "0967-2567",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - How Rousseau read Hume’s Political Discourses

T2 - hints of unexpected agreement in their views of money and luxury

AU - Susato, Ryu

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Despite mounting scholarship on the Rousseau–Smith connection, the possibility of overlap between the Humean and Rousseauian views of commercial society has not been explored. This is due to opposing views held by these two thinkers on this issue. However, Rousseau in the Confessions recorded a brief, but shrewd impressions on Hume’s Political Discourses, which he held before meeting Hume. In these comments, Rousseau, unlike his other French contemporaries, noted some republican aspects lurking in Hume’s political and economic essays. Moreover, after his two Discourses, Rousseau composed several other important works in which he revealed his more ‘mature’ economic arguments. Careful readings of these textual clues indicate that, in striking parallel with Hume, Rousseau conducts a thoughtful experiment on the drastic change in the quantity of money and elaborates on the significance of industry and a certain type of luxury. Our purpose here is not to prove that Hume’s Political Discourses directly influenced Rousseau’s later writings, but to measure the extent to which Rousseau could share the Scot’s economic ideas by considering that the former may well have read the latter.

AB - Despite mounting scholarship on the Rousseau–Smith connection, the possibility of overlap between the Humean and Rousseauian views of commercial society has not been explored. This is due to opposing views held by these two thinkers on this issue. However, Rousseau in the Confessions recorded a brief, but shrewd impressions on Hume’s Political Discourses, which he held before meeting Hume. In these comments, Rousseau, unlike his other French contemporaries, noted some republican aspects lurking in Hume’s political and economic essays. Moreover, after his two Discourses, Rousseau composed several other important works in which he revealed his more ‘mature’ economic arguments. Careful readings of these textual clues indicate that, in striking parallel with Hume, Rousseau conducts a thoughtful experiment on the drastic change in the quantity of money and elaborates on the significance of industry and a certain type of luxury. Our purpose here is not to prove that Hume’s Political Discourses directly influenced Rousseau’s later writings, but to measure the extent to which Rousseau could share the Scot’s economic ideas by considering that the former may well have read the latter.

KW - enlightenment

KW - Luxury

KW - quantity theory of money

KW - republicanism

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85053661894&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85053661894&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/09672567.2018.1499788

DO - 10.1080/09672567.2018.1499788

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85053661894

JO - European Journal of the History of Economic Thought

JF - European Journal of the History of Economic Thought

SN - 0967-2567

ER -