The Limits of a Confrontational Approach: Fabian Fukansai's Critiques of Neo-Confucianism and Christianity

研究成果: Review article査読

抄録

This paper analyzes the critique of Neo-Confucianism by the Japanese Jesuit Brother Fabian Fukansai (c. 1565-1621) in the Myōtei Dialogues (Myōtei Mondō) (1605), as well as Fabian's later critique of Christianity. It clarifies the author's understanding of Neo-Confucian theory and his apology for Christianity by analyzing his explanation of the Great Ultimate (Tai'kyoku/Taiji) and Principle (ri/li), which Fabian sees as nothing but an expression of Buddhist monistic mentalism. It also demonstrates that his explanations of the Great Ultimate and Principle have a crucial flaw: they do not sufficiently explain Zhu Xi's metaphysics, which tried to make the immanent and transcendental characteristics of the Great Ultimate and Principle compatible. This is because Fabian addresses only the elements of "local" religions including Neo-Confucianism with novel keywords that support the framework of Christian Creationism and the Anima Rationalis theory. However, his later work Deus Destroyed (Ha Daius), written after he had rejected Christianity, overturned his former claim by accepting the Neo-Confucian concept of Principle. Fabian's works are a historical example showing the potential limits of a confrontational approach toward other religions.

本文言語English
ページ(範囲)181-200
ページ数20
ジャーナルFrontiers of Philosophy in China
14
2
DOI
出版ステータスPublished - 2019 7 16

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Philosophy

フィンガープリント 「The Limits of a Confrontational Approach: Fabian Fukansai's Critiques of Neo-Confucianism and Christianity」の研究トピックを掘り下げます。これらがまとまってユニークなフィンガープリントを構成します。

引用スタイル